Alicent Converts Criston's Panic Into Loyalty
Plausibility Score
(?)Convinced
(?)#436
of 705 theories
Theory Ranking
(?)READER VERDICT
Is this theory convincing?
Trend builds after 10 votes.
Be among the first to weigh in.
THEORY ASSESSMENT
The episode's confirmed events — Criston's confession, Alicent's non-response, the suicide attempt, and her intervention — map directly onto the theory's mechanism, but the show does not yet surface Alicent's internal reasoning, leaving the strategic intent as inference rather than established fact.
STORY CONTEXT
Is Alicent a master player or a pawn of her father and sons? This thread debates whether she's driving Green strategy or increasingly sidelined, with close readings of her political maneuvering and moments of visible doubt.
WHY THIS MATTERS
If Alicent's sparing of Criston is strategic rather than compassionate, it reframes her as someone already constructing a faction rather than simply reacting to betrayal. It also means Criston's eventual ferocity toward Rhaenyra is not purely personal bitterness. It is the output of a calculated conversion that follows the same logic Otto used to place Alicent beside a grieving king.
Other Theories for S1E05
Larys Chose Alicent Over Chaos
Larys Strong is not a loyalist who found a patron.
Cole Killed Joffrey to Destroy the Man Who Would Have Said Yes
Criston Cole's murder of Joffrey Lonmouth was not a jealous outburst or a calculated silencing but a deliberate act of self-annihilation: a man destroying the negotiable, compromised version of himself before it could become permanent.
Daemon's Dance Is a Throne Play
Daemon's wedding conduct is a coordinated throne play in which Rhaenyra's desire for him is not the occasion for seduction but its deliberate output.
Rhea's Taunt Triggered an Unplanned Murder
Daemon did not ride to Runestone with the intention to kill.
Otto Made Alicent Believe Murder Was Inevitable
Otto Hightower's parting warning was not fatherly concern but a precision instrument: by framing Rhaenyra's threat to Alicent's children as structural rather than personal, he installed an unfalsifiable premise that converts Alicent from a grieving friend into an ideological enemy regardless of what Rhaenyra actually intends.